Overrated/Underrated.

The Guardian plays that wonderful game.

So, what do you guys think?

Here, I'll even go first:

Overrated:  Saint Iggy and (ack) Firestorm.  I'd also nominate the rancid Boy in Striped Pajamas, but I don't think enough people liked it to constitute an 'overrated' label.

Underrated:  This one I'll have to think about.  For now, though -- I've heard people in the book community rave about The Privilege of the Sword and Life As We Knew It, but I haven't heard a peep from anyone else about 'em.  I'll have to start talking them up even MORE.